Mixing Up Workouts as You Age: What Science Tells Us About The Benefits

Posted in:

Strength training is one of the best ways for older adults to maintain muscle mass, improve mobility, and stay independent. But what’s the best way to structure a workout plan? A study looked at different training methods to see which one older adults found most enjoyable and tolerable. The goal was to determine if certain workout structures made it easier for older adults to stick with strength training long-term.

The Study

Researchers recruited 41 older adults between the ages of 65 and 81. The participants were divided into three groups, each following a different type of strength training program for 22 weeks. They exercised three times per week, performing machine-based exercises like leg presses, chest presses, and seated rows.

The three training plans were:

  • Nonperiodized (NP): Participants performed the same exercises at the same intensity throughout the study.
  • Block Periodized (BP): Participants cycled through different intensity levels in structured blocks.
  • Daily Undulating Periodized (DUP): Participants varied their workout intensity more frequently.

Researchers tracked the total weight lifted, training monotony (how repetitive the workouts felt), and training strain (overall physical stress). Participants also rated how much they enjoyed and tolerated their workouts on a 7-point scale.

The Results

  • All three groups trained effectively: By the end of the study, there were no major differences in total weight lifted between the groups.
  • Adherence was high: More than 85% of participants completed their workouts, showing strong commitment across all training styles.
  • No difference in enjoyment: Participants in all three groups rated their training as equally enjoyable.
  • No difference in tolerance: All groups reported similar levels of tolerance for their workouts.
  • Injury and illness risks varied: The NP group had more missed sessions due to illness (21 sessions missed) compared to BP (8) and DUP (13). A few injuries were reported, mostly related to training to failure.

The Conclusion

The study found that older adults tolerated and enjoyed strength training regardless of how it was structured. However, using a structured approach like BP or DUP may help manage training stress better and reduce the risk of illness or injury compared to a rigid NP program.

What This Means for You

If you’re an older adult looking to start strength training, here are some key takeaways:

  • Any structured strength training can work: Whether you follow a simple or varied routine, you’ll likely enjoy and tolerate it just as well.
  • Mixing up workouts may help with recovery: Programs like BP and DUP provide variation, which may reduce the risk of fatigue, illness, and injuries over time.
  • Avoid training to failure: Pushing yourself to the limit in every session may increase the risk of strain and discomfort. Instead, try leaving a few reps in reserve.
  • Social support matters: Participants in the study enjoyed the social aspect of training. Finding a workout buddy or joining a class can help with motivation and adherence.

Strength training is important for maintaining health and independence as you age. The key is to find a structured, manageable routine that keeps you engaged and minimizes injury risks.

Sources:

  • Training Load Indices, Perceived Tolerance, and Enjoyment Among Different Models of Resistance Training in Older Adults – Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research
  • Periodization Strategies in Strength Training for Aging Adults – K. van Dijk
  • The Role of Exercise Variation in Long-Term Adherence – M. Schneider